Bundestrojan criticism: Security or massive basic rights violation?
Bundestrojan criticism: Security or massive basic rights violation?
Österreich - On June 18, 2025, the Ministry of the Interior in Austria presented the government template for a Bundestrojan who, despite massive criticism, has only experienced minor changes. The draft law provides for legalizing a national Trojan, which could endanger the safety of smartphones in Austria. It is classified as unconstitutional and disproportionate by various organizations. According to OTS is the lack of independence of control, the lack of technical feasibility and the massive safety risks through open security hits Core problems of the design.
The criticism of universities is particularly violent, lawyers: inside and civil society as well as from the SPÖ-related ÖGB, which had rejected the draft law during the election campaign, but are now defending in the government. The European Minister Susanne Plakolm also critically commented, but later had her statement deleted from the parliamentary website. The organization Epicenter.Works calls on the government parties not to decide on the law, since otherwise only the way to the Constitutional Court remains.criticism and uncertainties in implementation
The draft was sharply criticized by various institutions and associations. The Federal Ministry of Justice argues that the dangers for those affected and third parties are crucial for the proportionality of investigative measures. In addition, the University of Krems addresses the technical feasibility and warns of the use of foreign software from dubious sources. According to them, it would be better to rely on Austrian development.
various experts and organizations, such as the Austrian Computer Society, the Freedom of Information Forum and the Chaos Computer Club Vienna, have expressed concerns about massive interventions in personal rights. They show that security gaps could endanger not only people but also national IT security.
data protection and fundamental rights in the debate
The discussion about the Bundestrojan is not only limited to Austria. In a globalized context, data protection has gained international importance. According to das-wissen.de there are different legal framework conditions worldwide that influence the protection of personal data. In the EU in particular, strict data protection regulations such as the GDPR are in force that guarantee comprehensive rights via personal data.
In the debate about the Bundestrojan, it becomes clear that the EU considers data protection as a human right, while in other countries, such as the United States, economic interests are often in the foreground. A uniform standard for global data protection is considered necessary to cope with the challenges through technological developments and social requirements.
The uncertainties and the multitude of critical voices make an urgent need for a transparent and constitutional regulation. The coming days will be crucial to see whether the government takes the resistance to the Bundestrojan seriously and takes into account possible changes to the draft law.
| Details | |
|---|---|
| Ort | Österreich |
| Quellen | |
Kommentare (0)