Fact check for the Vice Presidential Batte Vance against Walz

Fact check for the Vice Presidential Batte Vance against Walz

At a memorable meeting in New York City, the democratic governor of Minnesota, Tim Walz, and the Republican Senator JD Vance from Ohio, met on Tuesday evening as part of their First and only vice-presidential debate . The two candidates had an exchange of blows on topics such as inflation, immigration, health care and the future of democracy.

Vance and the misunderstanding about Harris' role in border policy

Senator JD Vance claimed that Vice President Kamala Harris had been appointed “border commissioner” during the bid administration. "The only thing she did when she became Vice President and was appointed border officer was to undo 94 executive regulations from Donald Trump who opened the border," said Vance.

fact check: This statement by Vance is wrong. Harris was never officially appointed "border commissioner", a title that the White House always emphasized as inaccurate. The Minister of Internal Security, Alejandro Mayorkas, is the person responsible for border monitoring. In fact, in 2021 Harris received a restricted order that focused on diplomacy with El Salvador, Guatemala and Honduras to tackle the conditions, moved citizens to migration to the United States.

Walz about jobs through the Biden

Tim Walz praised the Inflation Development Act of 2022 of the Biden-Harris administration, an important climate law for which Kamala Harris in the Senate made the crucial vote. He spoke of the fact that the law had created "200,000 jobs in the country", including the manufacture of electric vehicles and solar panels.

fact check: This statement requires contextualization. Although the Inflation Development Act actually created many new jobs in the area of ​​clean energy, the number of "200,000" only comprises jobs that companies have promised but have not yet been specified. In addition, other surveys show lower numbers.

Vance about migrants in Springfield, Ohio

Senator JD Vance expressed that the schools and hospitals in Springfield, Ohio, were "overwhelmed" because of "illegal immigrants". "In Springfield and in communities across the country, we have overwhelmed schools and hospitals ... because we brought millions of illegal immigrants into the country who compete with Americans for scarce living opportunities," said Vance.

fact check: vances statement is misleading. We do not know the residence status of all immigrants in Springfield, but hundreds of thousands of Haitians have the official permission to legally live and work in the United States. The city of Springfield makes it clear that Haitian immigrants are legal here, and many of them have temporary protection status that protects them from deportation.

Vance on immigration commands of the bida-harris administration

Senator Vance claimed that the United States was experiencing a "historical immigration crisis" because Kamala Harris "wanted to reverse all border policy by Donald Trump" by "94 executive commands".

fact check: These statements are misleading. Even though the bid-harris administration actually signed numerous executive commands for immigration, Harris never said that she wanted to decriminalize illegal immigration through an executive order. Your views have changed over time.

Walz about project 2025 and a pregnancy register

governor Tim Walz claimed that the 2025 project of the Heritage Foundation provides for a registration of pregnancies.

fact check: This claim is wrong. Project 2025 does not provide for people to report their pregnancies to a federal authority. The plan is strictly directed against abortion, but does not include any provision for registration of pregnancies.

Vance on the number of illegal immigrants

Senator JD Vance said during the debate that “20 to 25 million illegal foreigners” lived in the country.

fact check: This number is significantly higher than most estimates. Although the exact number is difficult to determine, various reports come to the conclusion that the number is smaller.

vance on arms crime

Vance said that part of the problem with weapons in the United States is that Mexican drug cartels smuggle weapons into the country.

fact check: This statement is misleading. In fact, most illegal weapons from the USA are smuggled to Mexico, not the other way around. The Mexican government has repeatedly pointed out the problem that free weapons availability in the USA contributes to violence in Mexico.