Enttäuschung pur: Helene Fischers Show sorgt für massive Kritik!

On the first Christmas day, the "Helene Fischer Show" was broadcast on ZDF, which was recorded in Düsseldorf a few weeks earlier. Numerous colleagues from the hit industry were guest on the show, including Florian Silbereisen, Giovanni Zarrella, Maite Kelly and Marianne Rosenberg. The appearance of Marianne Rosenberg, who presented some of her most famous hits together with Helene Fischer, was particularly controversial. After just a few minutes, spectators expressed their symptoms about Rosenberg's singing, with the criticism mainly related to the use of Playback during their appearance.

On social media, the singing presentations of the singer were described as "bad" and "terrible". Spectators made comparisons to the "ZDF television garden" presenter Andrea Kiewel and pointed out that the ZDF used various technical tricks on the show, which questioned the quality of the live performance, how Merkur reported.

number of spectators and market share compared to the previous year

The "Helene Fischer Show" reached a market share of 16 percent and was therefore the most successful broadcast of the day. Nevertheless, there is a clear downward trend in the number of spectators compared to the previous year. In 2023, 26 artists were represented on the show, while in 2024 there were only 21. This development leads to criticism of the selection of guests, since the same stars often occur as Maite Kelly.

In addition, the frequent use of Playback was negatively commented on in the current edition. Marianne Rosenberg's vocal performances in particular were in the line of the spectators who complained about it. Helene Fischer himself also received critical feedback for her appearance with Robbie Williams. Fischer's fishermen criticized users and its influence on their performance, such as West-Ost-Medien