Var-Klat shocked Klagenfurt: Red card without video check!
Var-Klat shocked Klagenfurt: Red card without video check!
In the Bundesliga game between the GAK and Austria Klagenfurt on May 2, 2025, there was an extremely disputed decision. In the 49th minute, Daniel Maderner and 18-year-old Matteo Kitz got caught in the running duel. Referee Arnes Talic then showed Kitz the red card, although there was no intervention by the Video Assistant Referee (VAR). This decision led to massive criticism from Klagenfurt coach Carsten Jancker and managing director Günther Gorenzel.
Gorenzel asked the question in the room, for which the VAR is used if controversial decisions cannot be checked. He criticized that the VAR was not used, although Maderner described the scene as a elbow stroke, which for him justified the red card. Despite the outnumbered, Klagenfurt managed to secure an important point in the relegation battle.
The role of the var in football
The VAR or Video Assistant Referee was introduced to support referees in decision -making and to ensure fairer judgments. According to information from Pensal decisions, direct red cards and players. The system enables the referees to revise decisions based on the information that the VAR provides from four camera perspectives.
Especially in emotional moments of a game like that between GAK and Klagenfurt, the criticism of the Var becomes obvious. The referee's decision not to look for a obedient VAR-Rat in this situation remains particularly questionable, since the set of rules clearly defines that the VAR can be switched on in cases of direct red cards. This unclear location leads to further questions regarding the transparency and reliability of the VAR system in the Bundesliga.
an outlook on the future
With the introduction of the VAR in the Bundesliga since the 2017/2018 season and the second Bundesliga since the 2019/2020 season, the goal is clear: the improvements to the quality of the game through just decisions. However, such incidents as they appeared in the game GAK against Klagenfurt are seriously analyzed in order to strengthen the trust of the clubs and fans in the system. Gorenzel's critical note could be a first step to continue the discourse on the effectiveness of the Var and to avoid future misunderstandings.
In the context of the development of VAR in football, it is important to take into account both the technical and human dimension of decision -making. Early implementations in the Netherlands from 2016 and the use in various competitions worldwide show that the path of integration is complex, but remains essential for the fairness of the game.
| Details | |
|---|---|
| Ort | Klagenfurt, Österreich |
| Quellen | |
Kommentare (0)