Hamas and Israel argue about violations: does the fragile ceasefire keep?

Hamas and Israel argue about violations: does the fragile ceasefire keep?

The fragility of the Waffeistrasse between Israel and Hamas revealed when Israel Hamas accused Hamas of holding a hostage back. This resulted in the returned from the Gazastrip to their homeland in the north was.

The fragility of the ceasefire

The ceasefire contract was brittle right from the start, with Israeli statements often spoke of a "frame" and not of a specific deal. This week the tensions escalated when the 29-year-old Arbel Yehud, a civilian who was to be released on Saturday, not among the four freed women . As a result, Israel did not allow civilians from Gaza to return north over the Netzarim corridor, which should take place according to the ceasefire and the hostage agreement on Saturday.

Die Geisel in captivity

The Situation continues to complain because Yehud is not captured by Hamas. A high-ranking source from the Palestinian Islamic Jihad movement (PIJ), another militant group in the Gaza Strip, said CNN that she had Yehud in her violence and that it is "released as part of the agreed prisoner exchange". Both Hamas and Israel have accused each other not to comply with their obligations, which raises questions about the stability of the ceasefire, which needed more than 15 months to come about.

warnings and recommendations

"This is a very sensitive matter," said Gershon Baskin, a former Israeli hostage negotiator who previously communicated with Hamas via informal channels. He pointed out that Hamas "will not give anything for nothing" and added that "Israel's threat of displaced persons to deny the movement to the north" contributes little to convince Hamas to stand up for her release. Baskin warned that the implementation of this threat "could lead to a stop when the hostages were released," and advised Israel to keep the deal alive. "It would be better for Israel to speak less and let the brokers do more," he added, and asked Israel to signal Qatar and Egypt that it was willing to agree to the three -week agreement in September.

How does the US government react?

The military spokesman Israel, Daniel Hagari, said on Saturday that "Hamas did not meet the agreements by rejecting the return of civilians", and added: "We will insist that Arbel Yehud returns with the other hostages." Hundreds of displaced Fled after the Israeli army opened the fire on Saturday to deny them crossing to Nordgaza. The Israeli forces stated that they were "no harm" after their soldiers "made warning shots to drive out a crowd in Gaza".

propaganda and public perception

Hamas said that Israel "continues to prevent the conditions of the ceasefire and the prisoner exchange by closing the al-rashed road", which makes the return of the displaced people from the south into the north. The militant group blamed Israel for all delays in the implementation of the agreement and the possible effects on the remaining phases. "

meanwhile it is discussed how the USA under President Donald Trump will react to the violations claimed by both sides. An Israeli civil servant informed CNN that Israel asked the Trump administration to put pressure on Hamas in order to keep the conditions of the deal and to leave Yehud released. The message was transmitted to Trump's middle East Emissär, Steve Witkoff. CNN asked the Trump team to comment.

a complex negotiation environment

The "frame" for the ceasefire, as Israel calls it, "was not waterproof from the start," explained Dr. H.A. Hellyer, Senior Associate Fellow at the Center for American Progress and at the Royal United Services Institute. "The question is, after clear violations of the Israelis, how the United States will react. Will they exert pressure to ensure compliance, or are we experiencing a collapse of these breaks so soon after the signing?"

Despite the difficulties of maintaining the ceasefire, the militant group continued the second exchange of Israelaian hostages and Palestinian prisoners. She used the opportunity for a Warnings.