Carmen Geiss horrified: Court protects stalkers despite the threat of murder!

Carmen Geiss horrified: Court protects stalkers despite the threat of murder!

Aargau, Schweiz - The judgment of a Swiss court in the canton of Aargau causes horror. The entrepreneur Carmen Geiss was shocked by the decision that was made in the case of 38-year-old Steven S.. The man suffers from paranoid schizophrenia and had severely threatened and insulted the Geiss family, especially her daughter Davina. Some of the threats also included explicit threats of murder, and Steven S. announced that it would indulge women in a solarium because he incorrectly assumed that Davina had sent them to spy on him. He was in safety for 320 days at the time of the trial.

Although the court recognized in its decision that Steven S. had already served a prison sentence of five months and 45 daily rates, it surprisingly decided to grant him compensation of around 13,480 euros. A permanent inpatient measure was rejected what the public prosecutor and various reports had raised. Carmen Geiss asked the worrying question whether someone had to die before serious consequences for such threats follow.

Health and Justice

In Switzerland, the topic of mental illness and the treatment of those affected is particularly topical. According to a report by the Bern University of Applied Sciences, which analyzes psychiatric care in Switzerland, the number of coercive measures in psychiatric clinics has risen rapidly in recent years. Every year, around 16,000 people are affected by compulsory admissions, which makes the implementation of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Disabilities in 2014 appear questionable. This convention aims to protect people with impairments and reduce or abolish compulsory measures.

Another case that moves in the context of mental health concerns a 34-year-old Turk who was convicted of possession of drugs. Here, too, the Federal Supreme Court decided to stop the deportation of the man from Switzerland because he suffers from paranoid schizophrenia and depends on his mother's care. This decision shows that the Swiss judiciary is the right to respect family life in conflict with criminal regulations. In 2023, the Swiss courts ordered a total of 2250 national references, with 70 % of the convicts actually left Switzerland last year.

criticism of psychiatric care

The social and legal challenges in dealing with people with mental illness are obvious. Despite the recognition of human rights, the implementation in the psychiatric area remains insufficient. Critics see the lack of consideration of those affected in the planning and implementation of supply offers as well as the insufficient financing of support programs.

The arguments about mental health in society and the legal framework are in a complex context and require urgent need for action to ensure the rights and security of everyone involved.

For detailed information about the current situation in Switzerland, the reports are on OE24, Watson and BFH revealing.